Skip to main content

NYC public school teachers make emergency Supreme Court application to block Mayor Bill de Blasio's COVID-19 vaccine mandate from going into effect at 5pm Friday

New York City public school teachers have asked the Supreme Court for an emergency order to block Mayor Bill de Blasio's COVID-19 vaccine mandate from going into effect Friday. 

The group of four teachers sent a petition to Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor arguing that the mandate not only places an 'unconstitutional burden' on the city's 148,000 school workers, but also 'threatens the education of thousands of children.' 

The petition argues that their rights are being violated because they do not have the option to undergo regular COVID-19 testing instead of getting the shot. Other essential workers - including NYPD cops - have been given that testing option instead.

Teachers across all public schools in the Big Apple have up until 5pm Friday to get vaccinated against COVID-19 or risk losing their jobs. 

When the school day starts the following Monday - October 4 - all teachers and staff arriving for work across the city's public schools must have received at least their first dose of the vaccine. 

Unlike most vaccine mandates put in place such as by the federal government and private businesses across the country, the rule does not allow unvaccinated employees to undergo weekly COVID-19 testing instead of getting the shot.

Instead, anyone still unvaccinated by the deadline, will be ousted from their jobs.

New York City public school teachers have asked the Supreme Court for an emergency order to block Mayor Bill de Blasio's (pictured) COVID-19 vaccine mandate from going into effect

New York City public school teachers have asked the Supreme Court for an emergency order to block Mayor Bill de Blasio's COVID-19 vaccine mandate from going into effect

Pre-K students and staff at Phyl's Academy in Brooklyn, New York City. Teachers across all public schools in the Big Apple have until 5pm Friday to get vaccinated against COVID-19 or risk losing their jobs

Pre-K students and staff at Phyl's Academy in Brooklyn, New York City. Teachers across all public schools in the Big Apple have until 5pm Friday to get vaccinated against COVID-19 or risk losing their jobs

The New York Department of Education employs 148,000 school workers, including 75,000 teachers. 

De Blasio said Monday that 87 percent of all Department of Education employees in the city were already at least partially vaccinated, including 90 percent of teachers and 97 percent of principals. 

This means around 7,500 teachers - 10 percent of all those in the city's public schools - could be out of work by Monday.

Vaccination rates are lower - 82 percent - among other school workers, meaning thousands of support staff could also face the chop, plunging hundreds of schools into staffing crises. 

In the 12-page petition, filed Thursday, the group of teachers argues the City of New York, the Department of Education, and the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene 'created an Executive Order that places an unconstitutional burden on public-school teachers' - something they describe as the 'epitome of government overreach.'

The mandate 'forces unvaccinated public-school employees to go on unpaid leave for nearly a year', the petition says.

The group say the mandate unfairly forces teachers out of work when other city employees including those who are also in contact with children can instead opt for weekly testing.

The group of teachers argue that the mandate not only places an 'unconstitutional burden' on educators but also 'threatens the education of thousands of children'

The group of teachers argue that the mandate not only places an 'unconstitutional burden' on educators but also 'threatens the education of thousands of children'

They argue that teachers should also have the option to undergo COVID-19 testing rather than being forced to take the shot. 

'As the number of unvaccinated is small compared to that of the vaccinated, there is no basis to mandate vaccines in lieu of weekly testing,' the petition said. 

As well as the impact on school staff, the petition argues the mandate also 'threatens the education of thousands of children in the largest public-school system in the country and violates the substantive due process and equal protection rights afforded to all public-school employees.' 

The petition was sent to Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor (pictured)

The petition was sent to Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor

A spokesperson for the Department of Education pushed back on the petition telling CBS Local that the mandate is 'firmly grounded in science and the expertise of public health officials from across the nation.'

Sotomayor, who is the justice for the second circuit including New York, Connecticut and Vermont and so rules on emergency matters in the Big Apple, is expected to make a decision on the petition Friday - ahead of the vaccination deadline. 

The last-ditch effort from the group comes after weeks of toing and froing over the mandate which saw a temporary block lifted Monday. 

A Brooklyn judge earlier ruled in favor of the city, which led to a group of teachers filing an appeal.  

Last Friday, an appeals judge sided with the teachers, putting a block on the mandate going into effect.

This meant the city couldn't enforce the rule until a three-judge panel decided whether it was constitutional, forcing de Blasio to amend his rules and allow for weekly testing of staff.

But a panel of federal judges reversed this decision Monday evening, lifting the block and giving de Blasio's administration the green light to enforce the mandate. 

The 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan dissolved the temporary injunction Monday evening and denied the original motion.  

De Blasio announced back in August that all school employees - including teachers, custodians and cafeteria workers - were required to get at least their first dose of the COVID-19 vaccination by September 27.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Gambino family underboss dies in prison from 'health issues' at the age of 89: Daughter 'rushed to be by her father's side and he sang Frank Sinatra as he took his last breath'

Frank LoCascio, the Dapper Don's former underboss and acting consigliere, passed away Friday after serving 31 years of a life sentence A Gambino crime family underboss who stayed loyal to John Gotti even as the pair were hit with life sentences during a 1992 murder and racketeering trial has died in prison at age 89. Frank LoCascio, the Dapper Don's former underboss and acting consigliere, passed away Friday at the Federal Medical Center, Devens - a facility that houses federal prisoners with health issues - in Massachusetts. His daughter, Lisa LoCascio, was by his side as he took his last breaths.  LoCascio had been incarcerated for 31 years before his death last week after famously refusing to snitch on notorious mob boss Gotti during their infamous and highly publicized trial.  What's more, the high-ranking mafioso managed to cheat death during his three decades in the pen even with Gotti as his enemy, after the Teflon Don turned on him and put a 'contract' on hi...

The great class divide: Spending gap between private and state schools DOUBLES as they spend £6,500 more per pupil, study shows

Private school pupils have almost twice as much money spent on them as their state sector peers, a study shows. The Institute for Fiscal Studies found the gap has doubled over the last decade. While private school fees have risen by 23 per cent, per-pupil spending by the Government has fallen by 9 per cent in real terms after inflation. It meant average private school fees last year were £13,600 while state spending per pupil was around £7,100 – a gap of £6,500. In 2009-10, private school fees were £11,100 on average and state spending was £8,000, a difference of just £3,100. Private school pupils have almost twice as much money spent on them as their state sector peers, a study shows (stock image) The widening gap may partially explain why most state schools cannot keep up with the private sector in terms of grades and university admissions. Private schools on average pay higher wages to teachers, pride themselves on small classes and can usually afford better sporting facilities. Las...

Where do most people refuse the COVID-19 vaccine? See what place in the ranking is your state.

Reluctance to vaccinate is partly responsible for the recent delta epidemics across much of the United States. According to a recent US Census Bureau poll, 25.9 million Americans - or 10.4% of the population aged 18 and over - said they would likely or permanently refuse the vaccine. Depending on the state, the percentage of eligible individuals likely to refuse vaccinations ranges from 25.2% to 3.7% of the adult population. The Northeast is home to the states with the highest percentage of adults seeking the vaccine. Many Americans who have not yet been vaccinated report one of three reasons: they worry about possible side effects, they want to wait and see if the vaccine is safe, or they have trouble getting the vaccine. Others offer different explanations. 16.3 million adults, or 6.5% of the adult population, do not trust COVID-19 vaccines, while another 6,980,000, or 2.8%, do not think COVID-19 is a serious threat. Additionally, because they do not trust the government, 13.8 millio...